Fintech companies piggybacking on the backs of banks for access to the Depositor Compensation Scheme (DCS) for their savings products are raising hackles among non-bank deposit takers (NBDTs).
The DCS, which launched in July 2025, covers each depositor for up to $100,000 per deposit taker in the event of a failure, when money is held in DCS-protected accounts.
Building societies, credit unions and deposit taking finance companies - NBDTs - help fund the DCS through levies and face the scrutiny and compliance of being prudentially regulated by the Reserve Bank (RBNZ). Fintechs - pursuing technology-enabled financial innovation - aren't regulated by the RBNZ as deposit takers, and therefore aren't directly among the deposit takers offering DCS protected deposits.
However, several fintechs do offer savings accounts with DCS protection. So how do they do this?
Sharesies explains on its website.
"The money in your Save account(s) will be held on bare trust in a bank account opened in the name of Sharesies Nominee Limited with ANZ."
"As the money in your Save account(s) is held with ANZ, a licensed deposit taker, your Save account balance may be eligible for protection under the DCS. Because the DCS applies on a per person, per deposit taker basis, the total funds you hold across your Save account(s) and any eligible accounts you hold directly with ANZ will count towards the same $100,000 compensation limit with ANZ," Sharesies says.
"In the unlikely event the DCS is activated in respect of ANZ, any funds you hold directly with ANZ may be covered first as part of your overall compensation limit with ANZ."
"Sharesies Limited and Sharesies Nominee Limited are not licensed deposit takers and are not themselves covered by the DCS. The DCS does not cover losses arising from the failure of Sharesies Limited or Sharesies Nominee Limited."
Other fintechs that take deposits including Dosh and Squirrel Money operate in a similar way, with customers' money held on trust with licensed deposit taking banks.
'Not meant to be used that way'
Simon Jensen, a lawyer who specialises in acting for non-bank deposit takers and small banks, says the DCS was not meant to be used the way fintechs are using it.
"My understanding is the exemption for using a trust was included to deal with PIEs and not provide a backdoor way of fintechs offering insured deposits," Jensen says. "It is not in the spirit of the DCS, even if it may be within the letter of it."
"The fintech’s are using the DCS without the compliance obligations associated with it – they don’t have to have prepositioned customer bank accounts to receive payouts from the DCS, nor pay levies, nor be subject to the regulations relating to DCS and how it is advertised."
"New Zealand has no rules on how bare trusts like those used by fintechs must operate," says Jensen.
The RBNZ has a webpage about DCS coverage of non-regulated entities. Among other things this says; "If your money is held with an entity that is not on our list of licensed deposit takers that offer DCS-protected deposits, we encourage you to get independent advice on whether your money would be protected under the DCS."
Meanwhile a Ministry of Business, Innovation & Employment (MBIE) payment services regulation discussion document, seeking views on whether New Zealand’s rules for payment services are clear and fit for purpose, raises the issue of companies holding customer funds on trust with a licensed deposit taker. MBIE says trust arrangements can make it harder to assess how the DCS applies.
"The DCS is designed to protect eligible deposits in the event that a licensed deposit taker fails, up to a legal limit of $100,000 per depositor per institution. If a payment service provider holds customer funds on trust with a licensed deposit taker, such as a bank, and the licensed deposit taker fails, the extent of DCS protection in that scenario depends on the specific trust arrangement used and how it operates in practice," MBIE says.
'Isn’t that a good thing that fintechs are leveraging this?'
So what do the fintechs themselves say?
Squirrel explains that money in a Squirrel on-call account is held on bare trust across ASB and BNZ. Interest.co.nz asked if a saver has $100,000 directly deposited with BNZ, and also $100,000 with Squirrel that's in a trust with BNZ, how much are they eligible to get back via the DCS if BNZ fails?
Dave Tyrer, Squirrel's Head of Asset Management, notes the maximum you can get back from any one provider is $100,000.
"So in your scenario, the $100k held directly with BNZ would be covered. For the $100,000 held at Squirrel, approximately 50% would be lost on the assumption that Squirrel did not proactively move the funds to the other provider we have ahead of the failure."
"Part of the reason we hold the funds across more than one bank is to provide options in the event of banking system stress. As a custodian of investors money, we think we have a duty to do our best to support investors in this way," Tyrer says.
Asked whether the DCS was intended to be used in this way, and whether doing so is in the spirit of the DCS, Tyrer says Squirrel discussed the potential approach it would take with the RBNZ during the consultation period for the DCS.
"The Reserve Bank’s finalised rules supported the approach we wanted to take. One of the goals of the DCS was to encourage competition – isn’t that a good thing that fintechs are leveraging this?"
"The banks that fintech’s hold their funds with are paying the fee on the money we hold with them. The fintech’s don’t ‘get it for free’, the banks consider the fee they are paying on the money in their pricing to the fintechs," Tyrer says.
"Our view is the DCS is inherently mis-priced. For example, the NBDTs' credit ratings would suggest they should be paying a much higher fee than they are for the DCS, I’d argue the big banks fees are subsidising them. The NBDTs also get to leverage those deposits for their lending portfolio – the fintechs typically do not. Above all else, we value competition in the banking market in New Zealand."
"On compliance obligations, the fintech itself does not need to file returns to the Reserve Bank in relation to the DCS, that is the role of the bank. The fintechs do though need to meet anti-money laundering regulations, custodial and audit obligations, and any other licencing rules based on the way they are set up," says Tyrer.
Dosh is another fintech that holds customer funds on bare trust with banks covered by the DCS. Co-founder Shane Marsh says Dosh "made minor updates to its DCS webpage following engagement" with the Financial Markets Authority (FMA) and RBNZ in January.
Marsh says Dosh doesn't publish the names of the banks its customers' money is held with, but provides them to customers on request.
Asked if a customer has $100,000 directly deposited with ANZ, and also $100,000 with Dosh that's in a trust with ANZ, how much they're eligible to get back via the DCS if ANZ fails, Marsh says the RBNZ has acknowledged that this scenario is legally uncertain.
"Depending on the interpretation ultimately applied, the customer may have total coverage of $100,000 across both holdings, or separate coverage of up to $100,000 for each holding. Dosh’s trust arrangements and customer records are structured to identify each customer’s beneficial entitlement."
Asked if the DCS was intended to be used in this way, and whether doing so is in the spirit of the DCS, Marsh says the policy intent of the DCS is ultimately a matter for the RBNZ and Parliament.
"Holding client money on trust with banks is a long-established financial-services structure and was likely contemplated when the DCS legislation and regulations were developed. The licensed deposit taker holding the deposits is subject to the DCS regime and levies," says Marsh.
'That's crazy'
A company on a different tack is Wedge. Managing Director Dave McLeish says although they knew the DCS was coming, they decided becoming a deposit taker, "or simply finding clever ways to distribute bank deposits, wasn't going to help New Zealanders get ahead in the way we wanted them to."
"People told us they wanted certainty over what they're earning, transparency about what's backing their money, and access to it when they need it. That's essentially the foundation on which we built the Wedge Savings Fund. Members receive a published set rate, their money is backed by a diversified portfolio of AA-rated assets, and it's on-call. Their investments are also held in trust, entirely separate from Wedge's own finances, independently supervised by New Zealand Guardian Trust and regulated by the Financial Markets Authority."
"There are now quite a few fintechs offering bank-backed savings products. In most cases, they're simply giving people access to a better savings rate from the very same bank they should be getting that rate from directly. Instead, they have to go through a fintech's platform to get a better deal from their own bank. That's crazy. It really does show how poorly the banks treat their own loyal customers," McLeish says.
"Rather than getting into bed with the banks and relying on their deposit products, we wanted to use our experience as fund managers to give everyday savers access to a wholesale interest rate that is typically only be available to large, global institutions."
What would happen if a fintech failed?
Meanwhile, Jensen says if a fintech itself was to fail, its liquidators may look to challenge trust arrangements for the benefit of its general creditors. He believes a liquidator would be likely to seek directions from the Court before making any payment.
"Those payments are not DCS payments but the return of deposits from the relevant bank when due. My sense is the recovery process for a fintech depositor is much more challenging than for a bank depositor. If it is the deposit taker that has failed, I am not sure how good the rules are at capping protected amounts and ensuring that the scheme operates properly when the deposit taker’s liquidator has to look through the fintech arrangements to find the ultimate deposit taker," says Jensen.
For Dosh Marsh says customer funds are held separately from Dosh’s operating funds under trust arrangements with registered banks, and aren't used to fund Dosh’s operations.
"Any claims process is governed by the trust arrangements and applicable legislation," says Marsh.
Tyrer also says Squirrel holds investors funds in a trust and there's no co-mingling of investor money with Squirrel's operational funding.
"If Squirrel (the operating company) failed, then a back up servicer steps in to ensure investors are repaid. We have been very deliberate about our approach to ensure investor funds are safeguarded."
Jensen also questions how fintechs are offering higher interest rates than the banks, and suggests they are acting as brokers for the big banks by "white labelling bank products."
Tyrer says pricing between banks and fintechs is confidential to each arrangement, noting each fintech will have its own strategy and proposition for its customers.
"At Squirrel, we believe our margin is fair, with an ‘up to 25 basis points’ margin being deducted from what the bank pays the Trust. We’re very open and transparent on the balance we hold in this trust account, currently about $130 million."
"What’s a fair rate for a bank to pay for on-call/savings deposits of this size and nature? What Squirrel gets paid is probably fair in my view for $130m of on-call deposits that are retail in nature," says Tyrer.
"The real question is what is a fair rate for banks and NBDTs to pay for retail deposits they hold directly? The Reserve Bank data shows that as at Sep-26, registered banks pay on average 1.34% on retail savings/on-call accounts, with the Official Cash Rate at 2.75%, is it okay that banks make a larger margin than the interest they pay their customers? You can also argue that they can leverage some of this funding into their lending, meaning the real margin is even higher."
"My view is that everyone focuses their views on competition on the lending side of the equation. The banks make an outsize return from what they pay depositors. In some ways, the Reserve Bank opening up ESAS [exchange settlement] accounts for those that qualify means that fintechs could apply for an ESAS account and earn OCR on these funds," Tyrer adds.
'Not white labelling bank products'
He rejects the suggestion Squirrel is white labelling, or "simply re-badging" bank products.
"As an example, the banks charge Squirrel transaction fees, we do not pass those fees on to customers. We do not believe this is a ‘broker’ business model. A broker business model typically provides advice to the customer and attempts to place the customer with the best provider for that customer. In essence a fintech is an entity in its own right with its own propositions. The role of the fintech here is to try and deliver the best proposition that it can, not broker the business elsewhere," Tyrer says.
Marsh says the interest rates banks offer different customers reflecst the nature and terms of those arrangements and are ultimately a matter for the banks.
"Dosh does not white label bank products, so we can’t comment on how that model might apply to other providers."
A RBNZ spokesperson says it's important information on the DCS is accurate and any fintechs whose products are covered by the DCS are expected to provide clear and accessible information to their customers.
DCS levies for regulated deposit takers are calculated based on the Deposit Takers Act 2023 (part 6), the Deposit Takers Regulations 2025, and the Statement of Funding Approach.
"The regulations setting out the methodology for calculating levies will be reviewed in 2027 as part of an upcoming consultation on a range of Deposit Takers Act regulations," the Reserve Bank spokesperson says. "Essentially, the levy methodology takes into account a deposit taker’s riskiness and the amount of deposits that are DCS protected."
"Fintech customers’ deposits held with regulated entities will be included in the levy calculation for the deposit taker at which the fintech deposits are held, although the contribution they make to the levy raised will depend on the way the fintech is structuring its deposits."
The spokesperson notes the DCS logo is trade-marked and RBNZ regulated deposit takers may use the DCS logo in accordance with terms of use.
"Other entities should not use the DCS logo unless authorised to do so by the Reserve Bank. Where we find instances of misleading DCS advertising, we will be taking action. Please note that the FMA, as the conduct regulator and regulator of fintechs in New Zealand, may take its own actions in such cases. The Reserve Bank and the FMA work closely together on these matters," the RBNZ spokesperson says.
'Communicate clearly and accurately'
In comments attributed to Michael Hewes, its Director for Credit, Deposit Taking, Insurance and Advice, the FMA says it expects firms to communicate clearly and accurately about the financial products and services they offer, so consumers can make informed choices.
"Where a firm promotes deposits as being protected by the Depositor Compensation Scheme, it should be clear about the nature of the arrangement, including who the deposit is held with and the basis on which DCS protection applies. Firms should not create the impression that they are themselves a licensed deposit taker if that is not the case," says Hewes.
With the RBNZ set to issue its bi-annual Financial Stability Report today (Tuesday), it's interesting to note what it has said about the DCS and NBDTs in the previous two such reports. In November last year it said some NBDTs had seen both an increase in deposits and in the amounts they lend out for mortgages since the DCS was implemented. And in May this year it said housing lending by finance companies had risen over 30% since the DCS was introduced.
*This article was first published in our email for paying subscribers early on Tuesday morning. See here for more details and how to subscribe.
We welcome your comments below. If you are not already registered, please register to comment
Remember we welcome robust, respectful and insightful debate. We don't welcome abusive or defamatory comments and will de-register those repeatedly making such comments. Our current comment policy is here.