SBS Bank CEO Shaun Drylie hopeful the mutually owned building society will gain RBNZ approval for a Tier 1 capital instrument to help it meet the regulator's bank capital proposals

SBS Bank CEO Shaun Drylie hopeful the mutually owned building society will gain RBNZ approval for a Tier 1 capital instrument to help it meet the regulator's bank capital proposals

In this low interest rate world SBS Bank CEO Shaun Drylie suggests 3% could be something of a psychological barrier for term depositors.

Speaking to interest.co.nz after SBS posted a 16% rise in annual profit on Tuesday, Drylie says he thinks both deposit rates and mortgage rates may hit a floor soon, regardless of whether the Reserve Bank cuts the Official Cash Rate further from its 1.50% record low.

"Certainly a declining interest rate market does put more pressure on a bank, but you probably won't see the reductions happen in the lending rates to the degree that the OCR's going to come back. And likewise you won't see the reductions in the deposit rates to that degree," says Drylie.

"My thought is that we're pretty much going to hit a floor shortly."

Banks require deposits, or in SBS's case redeemable shares, to meet the Reserve Bank's core funding ratio requirements. To meet conditions of their banking registration with the Reserve Bank, banks' one year core funding ratio must be no less than 75% at the end of each business day. At March 31 SBS's core funding ratio was 96.53%. Nonetheless the issue of retaining retail funding is a key one for Drylie.

"We've done a little bit of backward looking just to see whether the rate reductions of previous years have changed the system significantly, and it doesn't seem to have hurt the system. The growth in bank deposit funds has remained reasonably strong even through a declining interest rate market which is an interesting parallel," says Drylie (pictured).

"We haven't seen that point reached before where you've seen significant substitution. And with probably a stabilising of the property market and maybe equity markets being a little bit more volatile, people may just hang on in there and not get the returns [from deposits] that they used to."

"The net return post inflation's still positive, but that doesn't help when people are relying on a certain amount of money to top up national super etc," Drylie adds.

"I think there's a bit of a psychological barrier once you go below 3[%], but whether that would have an impact on where people hold their money I'm unsure. Probably not, but it would certainly be a barrier that would create a bit of a psychological impact for many."

The average six month bank term deposit rate is currently 3.13%. You can see our coverage of banks' term deposit and mortgage rate changes after the Reserve Bank cut the OCR by 25 basis points in May here and here.

Term deposit rates

Select chart tabs »

The '1 year %' chart will be drawn here.
Loading...
(bank averages)
The '30 days %' chart will be drawn here.
Loading...
(bank averages)
The '90 days %' chart will be drawn here.
Loading...
(bank averages)
The '6 months %' chart will be drawn here.
Loading...
(bank averages)
The '2 years %' chart will be drawn here.
Loading...
(bank averages)
The '3 years %' chart will be drawn here.
Loading...
(bank averages)
The '4 years %' chart will be drawn here.
Loading...
(bank averages)
The ' 5 years %' chart will be drawn here.
Loading...
(bank averages)

Looking for a listed Tier 1 capital instrument to meet RBNZ proposals

On the Reserve Bank's proposals to increase banks' regulatory capital requirements, Drylie says SBS has been working with the regulator trying to find a Tier 1 capital instrument that enables it, as a mutual building society, to meet Reserve Bank requirements.

"The Reserve Bank has been quite helpful with us to date looking to find an instrument that strikes the right balance between their requirements and also what would appeal to the market. So we've been working through the Building Societies Act just to ensure that we meet those requirements as well. There's a couple of little changes that we may require in order to be able to issue a Common Equity Tier 1 instrument. So we're just working through that at the moment with advisers. But the Reserve Bank themselves have been quite open for an instrument that meets those requirements to be able to be issued, which would be great for us. It would allow us to be able to raise more capital without stemming the [bank's] growth," says Drylie. 

Any new Tier 1 capital instrument is likely to be NZX listed, but details are unlikely to be finalised until after the Reserve Bank announces the final capital changes in November. The Reserve Bank's proposals for increased bank capital are heavy on Common Equity Tier 1 Capital, which consists of ordinary shares and retained earnings, posing challenges for a mutually owned bank like SBS.

SBS already has capital bonds worth $92.879 million on issue including $31.411 million in Australia. The interest rate on these 10 year bonds is fixed for the first five years and then subject to a quarterly floating rate. The bank has the right to repay the principal amount on or after the five year anniversary but there is no right for a holder to redeem before maturity. These are issued as subordinated redeemable shares and rank behind redeemable shareholders, depositors and unsecured creditors of SBS and are subject to loss absorption provisions.

In total SBS has $132 million worth of subordinated redeemable shares on issue of which $72.2 million is recognised as Tier 2 Capital.

Holding 50% more capital

In terms of the Reserve Bank's capital proposals, Drylie is also keen to see the playing field evened out between the big four banks and the rest.

"We're holding probably about 50% more capital given the difference between the internal ratings approach that the Aussie banks use and our standardised approach. Same type of assets, same quality of assets when you look at arrears and write-offs etc, but we're carrying another 50% capital," he says.

SBS posted a $4.15 million, or 16%, rise in March year net surplus after tax to $30.818 million on Tuesday. This came with total operating income up $14.76 million, or 11%, to $152.580 million, and operating expenses up $8.7 million, or 10%, to $96.299 million. SBS's provision for credit impairment increased $523,000, or 3.5%, to $15.443 million.

SBS's March quarter net interest margin was 2.5% and its return on equity was 8.1%, according to Reserve Bank Dashboard figures.

(You can see our story on a combined submission on the Reserve Bank's capital proposals from SBS, TSB, Kiwibank and the Co-operative Bank here).

*This article was first published in our email for paying subscribers early on Wednesday morning. See here for more details and how to subscribe.

We welcome your help to improve our coverage of this issue. Any examples or experiences to relate? Any links to other news, data or research to shed more light on this? Any insight or views on what might happen next or what should happen next? Any errors to correct?

We welcome your comments below. If you are not already registered, please register to comment.

Remember we welcome robust, respectful and insightful debate. We don't welcome abusive or defamatory comments and will de-register those repeatedly making such comments. Our current comment policy is here.

5 Comments

Comment Filter

Highlight new comments in the last hr(s).

Why are NZ term deposit rates so elevated? ANZ will pay 3.20% and 2.00% respectively for 6 Month depo's in NZ and Australia, despite A$ cash rate being 25bp lower. In relative terms it's a huge margin and suggests NZ is structurally short of LCR qualifying investable funds.

ANZ Australia advertised headline special at moment is 1.3% for 12 months ($5k to $100k) well below a “3% physiological barrier”.
My wife has just bitten the bullet and has gone unconditional on a rental property. As a retiree, she would have much preferred to have had money in td, and despite very low yields and work involved in rentals, the outlook for td is too grim in the medium term so the deciding factor. We are provincial - Napier - and at the moment the property market outlook remains positive with some influx of Aucklanders cash rich. Also just gone unconditional on my mother’s house with a cash offer much higher than expected.
For those wanting to escape tds, personally I feel the options are limiting as the outlook for equities looks both volatile and grim with Trump, trade wars and slowing global economies.

Printer8 - Not to mention the imminent collapse of Deutsche Bank which will send shockwaves around the the world!

That is the exact point of lower yields - to force people to invest or consume. She made the right decision btw.

.