sign up log in
Want to go ad-free? Find out how, here.

Guy Trafford notes that China's 'dual circulation' policy development may crimp their dairy imports as they push a Five Year Plan goal of more local supply. Rising Chinese production may already be suppressing GDT results

Rural News
Guy Trafford notes that China's 'dual circulation' policy development may crimp their dairy imports as they push a Five Year Plan goal of more local supply. Rising Chinese production may already be suppressing GDT results

Whole milk powder dragged down the average price of the latest Global Dairy Trade auction.  Butter (+3.5%), cheddar (+0.7%) and skim milk powder (+1.5%) all had modest rises, but the WMP drop of -3.8% took the general average down by -1%.

While the reasons for the lower prices always include multiple factors both domestic as shown in David Hargraves report and international as referred to in a Rabobank summary, Chinese domestic production certainly appears to be ratcheting up and having an impact.

Rabobank reported higher levels of Chinese domestic production with an 8.1% increase in 2021 Q1 which appears to be rolling into Q2 and in addition to this they have been lifting their imported supplies. June 2012 had a 20% leap compared to 2020. These presumably high levels of stockpiles must be having an impact upon current demand and prices. 

Fonterra put the lowest volumes of WMP into the latest GDT auction and still prices fell.

Within China the “2021 China Dairy Top 20 Summit”  (D20) was held in Hefei. The theme of the summit was the goal of securing supply and safety and promoting 'dual circulation'. The CCP believe supply-side structural reform is vital for lifting the Chinese dairy industry to a new height during the 14th Five-year Plan period.  

The D20 summit called for measures to be taken as below:

  • strengthening the development of a high-quality milk supply base by genetic improvement of dairy cows and supply of high-quality fodder and hay;
  • enhancing comprehensive and broad supervision along the entire chain to further improve the quality and safety of dairy products;
  • supporting companies to increase the proportion of milk supplied from their own bases, and encouraging dairy farming-related recreation and sightseeing and other value-added services; and
  • further optimising dairy supply structure by accelerating the development of cheese and other dried dairy products adapted to the taste of Chinese consumers, and improving compatibility between the supply and demand of dairy products, and intensifying international cooperation and exchanges in diary industry.

In 2020, China’s dairy industry production was 35.3 million tons, up +7.0% year on year. All large-scale dairy farms have automated milking system in place and these account for 67% of dairy farms.

On the back of this development programme the RaboBank report shows that dairy heifer exports to China are up 60% in the last 6 months. But, with all the additional production occurring in several exporting nations Rabobank are also predicting a “cyclical downturn” from the end of the year and into 2022 and believe there is a “strong likelihood of a year-on-year decline in import volumes for Q4 2021 imports” (into China). Added to this, Australian milk production is up, as is Latin American volumes (up +3.3%).

Rabobank are still predicting a “wobbly” $8.00 per kg MS but are certainly also putting out some warning signs (alongside Westpac).


Support independent news. Go ad-free. Find out more.


In the not-too-distant background we still have COVID-19 yet again impacting on many of our markets. South-East Asia, for now, are being particularly hit and several countries in various forms of lock-down. This is bound to reduce demand for New Zealand dairy products.

Despite, or perhaps because of the rain that many areas of New Zealand have experienced the last few months, grass covers around the country are good. NIWA are predicting milder conditions for the earlier part of spring and if the near(ish) normal rainfall continues farming hopefully will be relatively stressless - at least on the feed supply.

Dairy prices

Select chart tabs

We welcome your comments below. If you are not already registered, please register to comment.

Remember we welcome robust, respectful and insightful debate. We don't welcome abusive or defamatory comments and will de-register those repeatedly making such comments. Our current comment policy is here.

10 Comments

scaremongering.

local Chinese milk production is to meet the demand for fresh milk only.

Up
0

So the live dairy cow export trade, with the goal of improving the genetics of the Chinese local herd, will bite NZ on the arse?

Up
0

We were supposed to sell China a fish everyday, instead we taught them to fish!

Up
0

China is always striving for self sufficiency and if they didn't buy heifers of NZ they would source them elsewhere, which they were anyway. They will always buy in dairy regardless.

Up
0

China is already buying a lot more heifers out of Chile according to some of my Chilean friends.
Keith W

Up
0

nz-it-worker
The main way that the Chinese have been improving their dairy genetics has been, and will continue to be, via US and European genetics with a focus on semen. NZ animals have largely been used to increase the scale of the Chinese industry, with these animals subsequently mated to American and European semen to get the the preferred type of animals for their conditions.
KeithW

Up
0

China are also aiming to be self-sufficient in timber by 2035 and they have subsidised timber imports to ensure that our sawmills couldn't compete (most are now closed down). Planned economies with actual strategies have their advantages I guess.

Up
0

What evidence do you have that they subsidised timber imports? They have no obvious reason to do that.
KeithW

Up
0

Having dealt with China for over 25 years Im puzzled where this comment is coming from. I have never seen any sign of subsidy - in fact they are very sensitive to price and are constantly scouring the world for cheaper options - as anyone would - I have seen a lot of mills and importers go broke over the years in China.
As for our mills - some closed down yes - its simply been a rationalization of small inefficient mills replaced by bigger efficient ones in NZ. Sawmills at the moment are having the best run ever - high local demand and amazing export demand (and prices) with no end in site. No mills are running out of logs as they can more than pay the export price and still make V V good profits. A lot of the export market is not China as well for them.
You need to remember trees take time to grow - you need labour (increasing problem in China as here), forest are being put on remote and Very hard land - there foresters are very good.
I have asked my Chinese friends who I have dealt with for many years about this and they just laugh - demand will change in time but 1.3 billion people is a lot of people to develop, rebuild and renovate.

Up
0

China will continue to struggle to meet their own internal demand for milk. The Chinese policy of promoting cheese consumption links to being considered by the Chinese Government as being a preferred source of protein within the Chinese diet. Cheese consumption is currently very low.
KeithW

Up
0