The ECB cuts rates, resumes QE. The EUR and German bond yields initially fell then moved higher. Market sentiment boosted by positive trade talk news giving both equity markets and the CNY a boost. NZD lower. The global bond sell-off extends

The ECB cuts rates, resumes QE. The EUR and German bond yields initially fell then moved higher. Market sentiment boosted by positive trade talk news giving both equity markets and the CNY a boost. NZD lower. The global bond sell-off extends

At the ECB meeting overnight, the central bank announced a 10bp rate cut to the deposit rate, as expected, to -0.5%, and the resumption of its QE programme, at a pace of €20b per month.  As widely expected, the rate cut was accompanied by the introduction of a “tiering” system, which exempts a portion of banks’ excess reserves from the negative deposit rate and is aimed at mitigating the negative impact on bank profitability, and hence banks’ willingness to lend.  The ECB also made the terms on its TLTRO more generous, lowering the interest rate and extending the maturities from 2 years to 3 years. 

While quantum of the QE programme was lower than analyst expectations of €30b per month, the ECB exceeded expectations on the duration, with the ECB statement saying that bond buying would continue until shortly before the ECB starts raising rates; this is effectively the ECB’s version of ‘QE infinity’.  There are some technical aspects around QE that don’t appear to have been clarified, such as how the ECB will prolong its programme when its holdings of German bunds hit its self-imposed 33% threshold (which analysts estimate could happen within a year).  Either the ECB will need to increase those thresholds or skew its purchases away from the ‘capital key’ (i.e. buying more Italy etc and less Germany going forward).  That may be left for incoming President Lagarde, who will conduct a strategic review when she comes in.  The ECB has previously bought bonds at an €80b per month pace. 

As foreshadowed by speeches and interviews by several ECB Governing Council members in the lead-up to the meeting, there was clear internal opposition to the resumption of QE.  According to Bloomberg, the governors of Germany, Holland, Austria France and Estonia, as well as two Executive Board members, opposed the plan, preferring to keep bond buying in reserve in case there were a crisis-like situation in the future.  Draghi again called out for governments to do more on the fiscal policy front, saying “there was unanimity…that fiscal policy should become the main policy instrument.”

There had been growing doubts in the lead-up to the meeting that QE might be relaunched at all, and the announcement immediately sent the EUR and European rates lower.  The EUR reached a low of 1.0927, near its lowest level since 2017, but it swiftly bounced back and is now trading at 1.1065, 0.5% higher on the day.  Likewise, the German 10 year bund yield fell 6bps to -0.64%, but it has had a 12bp round trip and now sits at 0.52%.  Positive news on US-China trade (see below), unwinds of speculative positions, and possibly some doubts among market participants around the ECB’s resolve (and ability) to deliver more stimulus – given the internal opposition to QE – explain the reversal in market rates.  Encouragingly for the ECB, inflation expectations moved sharply higher, with the 5y5y inflation swap rising 8bps to 1.3%, and long-dated peripheral bond yields fell sharply, with Italy’s 10 year yield falling 10bps to 0.86%. 

There have been incrementally more positive reports on US-China trade relations over the past 24 hours that have boosted broader market sentiment.  Bloomberg reported that some Trump advisors had discussed offering a limited trade deal to China which would roll back tariffs (i.e. see the September tariffs unwound, with the tariffs planned for October and December not implemented) in exchange for a commitment from China to buy more agricultural goods and strengthen IP protections.  The proposed mini-deal had not been run past Trump as yet and CNBC later quoted a senior White House source as saying it was “absolutely not” considering such a measure.  Yesterday, Trump announced that the planned tariffs for October 1st would be delayed until the 15th of the month as a goodwill gesture, which the editor of the Global Times said would create “good vibes” for the upcoming trade negotiations.  And China is also reportedly considering whether to increase its purchases of US agricultural goods in the lead-up to the October trade talks as a goodwill gesture on their side.  While market participants are naturally sceptical that there will be a ‘grand deal’ anytime soon between the two countries, the trend in relations between the two countries at least appears to be heading in the right direction. 

Amidst the round-trip in European rates after the ECB, more positive reports on US-China trade and clear signs that market positioning has been caught wrong-footed, the global bond sell-off has extended.  The 10 year Treasury yield has increased 5bps on the day to 1.79%, from a post-ECB low of 1.67%.  A stronger than expected US core CPI release, which rose to an annual rate of 2.4%, added further impetus to the move higher in rates.  Used car prices, one of the factors that had depressed core inflation earlier in the year, showed another outsized rise on the month, boosting the overall core index.  NZ’s 10 year swap rate rose 4bps yesterday to 1.42% and we should expect that move to extend further today given the overnight moves. 

The USD is weaker overnight, by 0.2% to 0.3% in index terms, largely reflecting the appreciation in the EUR and other European currencies after the ECB meeting.  The risk-on market backdrop, which has seen the S&P500 rise another 0.6% overnight, and rise in Treasury yields has resulted in further gains in USD/JPY, which has moved up to 108.15, its highest level in six weeks. 

Surprisingly, the better news on the US-China trade front, which has seen the offshore renminbi (CNH) strengthen by 0.6%, the improvement in market sentiment, and the rise in the EUR hasn’t done anything to help the NZD.  The NZD has fallen away from an intraday high of 0.6451 to around 0.64 and it is now 0.2% lower on the day.  The AUD is unchanged on the day, at 0.6865, and also hasn’t benefited from the appreciation in the CNH as one would have expected, given the tight correlation between the two currencies since the trade war erupted. 

The NZ manufacturing PMI, which fell into contractionary territory last month, is released this morning. 

We welcome your help to improve our coverage of this issue. Any examples or experiences to relate? Any links to other news, data or research to shed more light on this? Any insight or views on what might happen next or what should happen next? Any errors to correct?

We welcome your comments below. If you are not already registered, please register to comment.

Remember we welcome robust, respectful and insightful debate. We don't welcome abusive or defamatory comments and will de-register those repeatedly making such comments. Our current comment policy is here.

1 Comments

Comment Filter

Highlight new comments in the last hr(s).

Headless chickens. ECB says need fiscal policy move which EURO rules forbid in any effective manner.
Fiscal policy expansion is what Neo-liberal independent banks etc were designed to stop as capital regarded itself as being whipping boy class for helping "society." Plus did we not have a "sovereign debt crisis" a wee time ago the solution for which was LTRO? Farce as a word does this chaotic musical chairs no justice. Germany and Italy are in recession because China is in much worse state than they let on or anyone else wants to admit. The Neo-liberal propagandists and government representatives have had their own way for 41 years and here we are in this mess and all they can say is: more of the same. Interest rates must be cut to induce people to take on more debt in lieu of wage rises they no longer get thanks to the glories of globalisation. Sold a pup