Fonterra is now planning to sell part of its ill-starred investment in China's Beingmate on-market having failed to find a buyer for the whole 18.8% stake

Fonterra is now planning to sell part of its ill-starred investment in China's Beingmate on-market having failed to find a buyer for the whole 18.8% stake

Giant dairy co-operative Fonterra now says it's going to start offloading part of its ill-starred investment in China's Beingmate on market, having failed to find a buyer for the whole 18.8% stake.

The announcement by Fonterra on Wednesday is a continuation of the tale of woe for the Beingmate investment, talked up as a "game changer" for Fonterra by then Fonterra CEO Theo Spierings in 2014.

It has been an unmitigated disaster.

Fonterra ended up investing in March 2015 the sum of $756 million for 18.8% of Beingmate Baby & Child Food Co. 

Last year Fonterra took a $405 million hit on the Beingmate stake and presumably there will be more ramifications from the Wednesday announcement that the shares are now to be sold on market.

At the time the write-down was made last year, Fonterra was holding the Beingmate stake on its books with a value of about NZ$244 million.

Based on the current Beingmate price of a little under 5 yuan (Fonterra paid 18 yuan), the stake would be worth around NZ$207 million. Arguably of course, the announcement by Fonterra that it intends offloading shares on the market may well put downward pressure on the share price.

Current Fonterra chief executive Miles Hurrell says the co-operative had "talked to a number of parties regarding the potential sale of our entire stake in Beingmate, but so far have been unsuccessful in finding a buyer".

“As a result of this, we are now considering selling part of our holding and, as required by local listing rules, need to pre-announce our intention.”

Hurrell said subject to demand for the shares, under the Shenzhen Stock Exchange market rules it is only possible to sell up to 1% every 90 days directly on the exchange, or sell up to 2% in a single block every 90 days. Trades greater than 5% can be made to an individual party in an off-market transaction.

“From here, it’s about making pragmatic decisions to get the best outcome for the Co-op from our holding in Beingmate,” Hurrell said.

“China will always be one of our most important markets. We’ve got a strong business there and are still very much focused on the areas in China where we can succeed.”

There's no indications in the release from Fonterra as to the financial implications of the non-sale of the Beingmate stake.

The sale of the stake was one of the targeted realisations for Fonterra through which it intended to reduced its debt levels by $800 million by the end of the July financial year. 

One big deal brought to fruition was the sale of the Tip Top ice cream business for $380 million.

Fonterra has previously indicated it was on target to meet that debt reduction goal, but gave no update in Wednesday's release.

Hurrell said as part of its efforts to turn Fonterra around it had  "re-evaluated every investment, major asset and partnership to ensure they still meet the co-operative’s needs today".

“This started with a strategic review of our relationship with Beingmate, which has been disappointing.

“The first action in this review was bringing the distribution of Anmum in China back in-house under our management. 

“We then ended the Darnum joint venture with Beingmate, bought back Beingmate’s share of our Darnum facility in Australia, and entered into a multi-year agreement for Beingmate to purchase ingredients from us.

“What remains is our shareholding in Beingmate Baby & Child Food Co., which we now view as a financial investment only."

We welcome your help to improve our coverage of this issue. Any examples or experiences to relate? Any links to other news, data or research to shed more light on this? Any insight or views on what might happen next or what should happen next? Any errors to correct?

We welcome your comments below. If you are not already registered, please register to comment.

Remember we welcome robust, respectful and insightful debate. We don't welcome abusive or defamatory comments and will de-register those repeatedly making such comments. Our current comment policy is here.

18 Comments

Comment Filter

Highlight new comments in the last hr(s).
13
up

these guys make disaster look normal when it comes to chinese investments
how much have they lost in china up to date, i bet a lot was hidden in the accounts to make it look better

... to paraphrase the property bulls : " you can't lose with being , mate ! " ...

How amazingly Fonterrible .... and are we surprised ?

...farmer shareholders ought to be cheesed off ...

They are going to take another bath on this one. Beingmate share price tanking:

http://www.szse.cn/English/siteMarketData/siteMarketDatas/lookup/index.h...

Remind me, how much was Spierrings paid?

Andrew Ferrier, his predecessor was paid over $8million also.

At least Hurrell is talking sense. They have removed any relationship with Beingmate so the fleas attached to such a dog are no longer clouding Fonterra's judgement. Now there are purely and simply investment or business decisions on how to maximize whats left. The emotional cloud of what could have/should have been and who to blame is no longer screwing with managements and suppliers minds.

What happened to Theo anyway, where is he now? Maybe he would like to buy such a sure thing.

The Board ultimately made the decision on Beingmate

It certainly was a game changer!
What I would like to see are consequences for people including the people Fonterra put on their board.

Why is NZ so lenient on incompetency?

In many cases, incompetency is even rewarded.

Funny....

13
up

Mao was one of the most incompetent leaders in history. He managed to kill 20mm++ people and wipe the slate clean on Chinese culture and yet his picture still sits on the front gate of the Forbidden City. President Xi has managed to send 2mm ethnic minorities into concentration camps but he is now president for life.

China seems to beat NZ for incompetence don't you think ?

China is highly incompetent in terms of its humanity.

Thank goodness mum and dad dairy farms are disappearing as the industrial farms take over (4500 fewer dairy farms in 2016 than there were in 2002. Land area per farm increased 10.3% over the same period). Fonterra's stuff-ups are increasingly hurting factory farms rather than family outfits.

“As a result of this, we are now considering selling part of our holding and, as required by local listing rules, need to pre-announce our intention.”

This is commercially sensitive information, do the listing rules really require them to disclose it prior to disposal?

Are the rumours true about the top Fonterra executive bonuses received upon completion of a successful Beingmate purchase from the Beingmate people? Sort of similar to Westland Milk payouts to their top managers from their new Chinese owners on successful completion of their buyout. Theo should be able to tell us.

‘Beingmate’ - what a strange name

Its an absolute lemon isn't it !

"China will always be one of our most important markets." Given the evolving geo-political climate, China's economic downturn and the simple fact that China is now governed under a modern form of the national socialism of 1930s Germany......I think they ought to reconsider that statement. And quickly.