Summary of key points: -
- Monetary policy and election risks for the Kiwi dissipate
- Two major Kiwi dollar vulnerabilities lie ahead: -
- Covid damage and solutions for the NZ economy
- Equities bull-run ends abruptly
Monetary policy and election risks for the Kiwi dissipate
As expected, the NZD/USD exchange rate has corrected back downwards from highs of 0.6700 two weeks ago to nearer 0.6500.
However, the extent of the pullback has been limited by ongoing US dollar weakness on global FX markets.
Whilst the US dollar exchange rate against the Euro has stabilised around $1.1800 after being sold-off through June and July, there are no signs of any short-term recovery in the US dollar’s value that would allow for a lower NZD/USD rate.
The previous cited short-terms risks for the NZ dollar, being increased Quantitative Easing (“QE”) from the RBNZ on 12 August and political risk ahead of the 19 September election have played through or changed without causing significant downward pressure on the currency.
The RBNZ delivered the increased LSAP amount as expected and kept negative interest rates on the table for the future (as anticipated).
Currency markets, including the NZ dollar market, have rapidly concluded that the RBNZ’s monetary policy levers to influence behaviour in the economy have become increasingly impotent.
As everyone’s interest rates are zero or close to zero now, interest rate differentials or changes are having no impact on exchange rates.
An additional tool the RBNZ say they have ready to apply alongside negative interest rates is a direct term lending facility to banks to on-lend to businesses. The problem with that is you still come up against bank credit/lending policies (as the failed 20% Government guarantee scheme through the banks found out).
The second issue is that most businesses do not want to borrow more debt (outside of working capital requirements) even if the cost of that debt is very low or zero. Negative interest rates have not worked in Japan or Europe and the Aussie have ruled them out, so the RBNZ’s persistence in threatening them is more about optics to keep the NZ dollar lower than it would otherwise be.
The political risk for the Kiwi dollar has not entirely gone away, however it will be delayed in time as the PM is expected to announce a postponement of the general election to a later date.
With political party election campaigns now on hold whilst the country is in level 2 and level 3 lockdown mode, democracy would not be served by continuing to hold the general election in a month's time. PM Jacinda Ardern’s previous election manifesto of the successful control of Covid (and not about policies) is now in tatters with the recent infection outbreak in Auckland.
Two major Kiwi dollar vulnerabilities lie ahead
Looking ahead, the Kiwi dollar now has two major vulnerabilities: -
- Ongoing economic damage from our Covid elimination strategy not working and therefore we have painted ourselves into a corner.
- The US equities bull-run ends abruptly as investors start to bank unrealised profits. Investor “risk-off” mode is always negative for the NZ dollar.
Covid damage and solutions for the NZ economy
Once again, it seems that it is the business community (and the livelihoods of business owners/operators) are the ones paying the price for another Government imposed lockdown that damages the economy.
Irritation and frustration are rising as the Government is forced into draconian knee-jerk action to contain the new outbreak. Perhaps the return of Covid was inevitable given what is occurring in Melbourne, however one that may have been preventable with tight border/quarantine control (which we were told was in place).
Media columnists and commentators are good at identifying the problems and criticising the Government (politicians and bureaucrats) on the predicament we now find ourselves in with the Covid pandemic. However, they tend to be short on providing solutions. Here are some suggested solutions for the short-term and medium term that will reduce the risk of ongoing economic damage.
- Short term solutions: Hard-arsed discipline and control needs to be implemented/policed to ensure “secure” quarantine facilities are actually secure and infected people tightly controlled i.e. armed guards and electrified fences. Catering for the idiots is what you have to do. Human rights, privacy laws and political correctness may need to take a step back in the interests of households being able to put food on the table. No-one should have the right or ability to “refuse” a Covid test. “Compulsory” may not be the New Zealand way for some, but right now it is the only way and needs to be enforced.
- Medium term solutions: Total elimination of Covid and thus cut-off from the rest of the world in our South Pacific bubble is not a viable solution for the economy. Suppression of the virus and living with it in a controlled fashion is the only answer for the economy to function. Using smart technology to swiftly control infection hotspots is another solution. The Bluetooth ID card proposal was submitted to the Government in early June, it seems to be bound up in red tape in the typical Wellington way. Eventually the borders have to be reopened as tourism is our second largest industry. Testing and clearance of people before they arrive in New Zealand has been poo-pooed as unsafe because certificates or health passports can be easily frauded and are outside our control. We can wait for a Covid vaccine (smallpox was only eliminated after 20 years of a vaccine being available) or we can invite the private sector to come up with smart solutions to these issues.
The current Government does not appear to have a medium-term plan for living with the virus and allowing the economy to function normally. Throwing borrowed cash at self-imposed lockdowns is not a plan or policy prescription. Sadly, many people seem to have lost their moral compass in thinking that we can keep borrowing with no limit and it is justified to send the bill to the grandchildren.
Equities bull-run ends abruptly
Predicting the timing of when the equities bubble will burst, and how badly it will burst, is fraught with risk. No-one knows the timing with any degree of accuracy. However, whenever it commences the downside risk for the Kiwi dollar increases at that time.
In the meantime, the greater medium-term risk for the NZD/USD exchange rate is continued US weakness on the global stage. As the Federal Reserve and the RBNZ both continue with QE money printing the exchange rate impact is offsetting.
The forecast USD depreciation comes from the US needing a lower currency value to attract in foreign investors to fund their ballooning Government budget deficits and debt.
As the chart below shows, the US dollar was considerably weaker at 80 on the index when the US Government budget deficit plunged to 10% of GDP in 2009. It is now 15% of GDP.
*Roger J Kerr is Executive Chairman of Barrington Treasury Services NZ Limited. He has written commentaries on the NZ dollar since 1981.